03 / Interpretation history
How the reading changed.
18 August 2026 · transcription verification
Yale howard retranscription
- Original claim
- Howard's day-21 wind appeared compatible with Constable's inscribed East, but Nephos's first NE reading came from OCR row-counting and was explicitly marked for a page-image check before archival citation.
- Conflicting evidence / limits
- The first NE reading came from OCR row-counting and was explicitly unready for archival citation. Direct inspection on 18 August 2026 established that Howard's cell reads NE, not E; it is also from a different London location than the assumed Hampstead site.
- Current conclusion · Partially agrees
- Direct inspection established the transcription, while source distance and the non-identical directions kept the comparison at partial agreement.
- Supporting sources & retained versions
- Pre-verification Nephos machine record, commit 6ae6c62 (OCR row-count caveat) Verified Nephos machine record Howard September 1822 page image Yale Nephos record
Recorded in the 2 September 2026 discrepancy packet · exact change date not retained
Yale cloud amount comparison
- Original claim
- The Yale capture segmentation measured 58% opaque cloud while the 20th Century Reanalysis ensemble mean was 61% cloud, with ±33 percentage points of ensemble spread, over the London-area grid cell.
- Conflicting evidence / limits
- The 61% ensemble mean carries +/-33 percentage points of spread over a regional 1-degree grid cell, while 58% is a capture-specific paint segmentation rather than an atmospheric observation.
- Current conclusion · Partially agrees
- The three-point proximity is presented only as compatibility within wide uncertainty.
- Supporting sources & retained versions
- Verified Nephos machine record NOAA 20th Century Reanalysis v3 Yale Nephos record
7 September 2026 · presentation revision
A research companion around the existing evidence.
Findings moved forward; source-language comparisons and production limits made explicit. No new weather observation or independent validation was added. Read the preserved pre-rework page. The archive label identifies this predecessor snapshot; its original edit time was not recorded.